Short answer
For full songs with vocals, Suno is a strong candidate and is moving to models licensed through its Warner Music deal, while ElevenLabs' Eleven Music is built for commercial use from the start and suits videos, ads and podcasts. Which one is worth it depends less on sound quality than on what you plan to do with the result, because the plan you pay for decides what you may download and publish.
Follow-up question What do their licences allow?
An AI music generator turns a written description, such as "a gentle acoustic song about the first snowfall, female vocals," into a complete track, often with sung lyrics. For a while the main questions were whether the songs sounded convincing and whether the tools were legal. The legal picture is now changing through licensing deals with record companies, so the practical question has shifted to fit: which tool matches your purpose, and what are you allowed to do with what it makes?
What changed with the label deals
In 2024 the three major record companies sued the two best-known song generators, Suno and Udio, saying they had trained on recordings without permission. In November 2025 Warner Music Group, one of those three, settled with both.
The Suno agreement comes with product changes. Suno said it would release new models, trained under licence, to replace its existing ones during 2026. Downloading audio will require a paid account; free users will be able to play and share songs on Suno but not download them. Warner's artists and songwriters also get to decide whether their names, voices, likenesses and compositions can be used in AI-generated music. The Udio agreement covers a new licensed music creation service that Warner said was set to launch in 2026.
When those deals were announced, Universal Music and Sony Music were reported to be negotiating with both companies rather than settled. If you plan to publish commercially, check the latest status before you choose a tool.
ElevenLabs, an AI audio company, took a different route. When it launched Eleven Music in August 2025, it said the model was made in collaboration with labels, publishers and artists and that its output may be used commercially in most settings, including screen productions, podcasts, games, social video and advertising.
A worked comparison
The table compares the three by purpose. The "best for" column is a reasonable reading of each company's own description, not a sound-quality test.
| Suno | Udio | Eleven Music | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it makes | Full songs with vocals from a prompt and optional lyrics | Songs; a new licensed service announced for 2026 | Songs or instrumentals, with section-by-section editing |
| Best for | Personal songs, demos, creators who want a finished track | Depends on the new service | Background music for videos, podcasts, ads and games |
| Commercial use | Paid plans only (see below) | Depends on the new service's terms | Cleared for most commercial uses; details vary by plan |
| Free tier | Play and share; downloads moving to paid plans | Depends on the new service | Check the current plan page |
How to choose, in three questions:
- Where will the music go? A song for a birthday or a family video has few restrictions. A track in a paid ad, a monetized channel or a client project needs clear commercial rights.
- Do you need to edit parts of it? If you want to change one verse or swap the instruments in a bridge, section editing matters more than the quality of a single take.
- Do you need it in your own software? If you are building an app or an automated workflow, you need an API, a way for programs to call the tool directly; Eleven Music launched with one.
Try it: Write one prompt for a 30-second instrumental intro for a podcast, including tempo, mood and instruments. Run it in two tools, then note for each one whether you could legally use the result in a sponsored episode under the plan you are on.
A good prompt for any of them
Music generators respond best to the same ingredients: genre, mood, tempo, instruments, voice and structure. For example:
Upbeat indie folk, about 110 BPM. Acoustic guitar, light hand claps,
warm upright bass. Female lead vocal, close and friendly. Structure:
short intro, verse, chorus, verse, chorus, gentle outro. Theme: a
small-town farmers' market on a sunny Saturday morning.Write your own lyrics if the words matter. Lyrics you wrote yourself are your own work, which also helps on the rights question.
What do their licences allow?
Start with the plan, not the song. Suno's terms of service, in the version dated June 2024, draw a firm line between free and paid use. On the free tier, songs may be used only for personal, non-commercial purposes, and you must credit Suno. For songs made while on a paid Pro or Premier subscription, Suno assigns its rights in the output to you, so you can release and earn from them. Two cautions apply even then: Suno says it cannot promise that copyright exists in an AI-generated song, and you must own or have permission for anything you upload, such as lyrics or audio. Because Suno is changing its models and download rules under the Warner deal, read the current terms and note their revision date before you publish.
Eleven Music is presented as commercially cleared, with labels and publishers involved in its creation, but ElevenLabs states that what you may do differs between its plans. Check the plan you are on, particularly for broadcast, advertising or resale.
Whatever the tool, keep a simple record for each track you publish: the tool, your plan on the day you made it, the prompt, your lyrics and the date. If a platform, a client or a distributor asks where a song came from, that record answers the question in a minute.
Sources
- Warner Music signs deal with AI music startup Suno, settles lawsuit — TechCrunch (Aisha Malik), November 25, 2025
- Eleven Music is here — ElevenLabs, August 5, 2025
- Terms of Service — Suno, June 30, 2024